Tuesday, January 19, 2010

King Lear Journal 4

"When the mind's free,
The body's delicate. This tempest in my mind
Doth from my senses take all feeling else
Save what beats there." (3.4, 13-17).

Context: Lear is outside in the storm, talking to the storm about his daughters and their betrayal. He is agonizing over why they have turned against him even though he has given him so much.

Lines on their own:
When the mind is not troubled by anything,
The body is sensitive. The storm in my mind
Takes all the feeling from my senses
Except for the feelings in my mind.

Lines together in context: In this statement, Lear is saying that when a person is not troubled by anything in their mind, their physical body is more sensitive to pain. But when the person's mind is troubled, they are too pained by that trouble to be sensitive to physical pain any storm can inflict on them. For example, Lear does not mind being outside in the violent storm because he is too focused on agonizing over his daughters than he is aware of the discomfort inflicted on him by the storm. If he had nothing weighing down his thoughts, he wouldn't be willing to stay out in the storm.

Personal Response:
To me, this passage shows a surprising side of Lear. For one thing, I'm not used to hearing him share pieces of wisdom like this one. Usually he speaks much more bluntly and non-poetic, but these lines are surprisingly flowy and meaningful. After reading this passage, I also see a different side of Lear that I had not before. Previously, it has seemed to me that Lear was just being selfish and stubborn in insisting he be accompanied by 100 knights at his daughters' houses. However, this passage makes me see that part of Lear actually feels hurt by his daughters' unwelcoming attitudes towards him. He is an old man with no power or land left, and he only wants to spend time with his daughters; however, they are shunning him (and possibly planning to overthrow his kingdom). I didn't expect to ever change my perspective on him so much, but this passage actually makes me feel a little sorry for Lear, who just needs family to fall back on and is being let down by his daughters whom he thought loved him but are not welcoming him in to their homes.

Tuesday, January 12, 2010

King Lear Jounal 3

The motif I have been tracking is the idea of keeping secrets and withholding information. Two passages that show this motif are:

"Edmund: I do serve you in this business.
A credulous father and a brother noble,
Whose nature is so far from doing harms
That he suspects none; on whose foolish honesty
My practices ride easy. I see the business.
Let me, if not by birth, have lands by wit" (1.2, 186-191).

In this passage, Edmund reveals his secret plot to turn his father against his brother, Edgar, so that he will get the land inheritance instead of Edgar. Since Edmund is an "illegitimate" child, this seems to be his only chance at gaining the inheritance. I chose this quote because it is an example of the motif of secrets. Edmund keeps his plot a secret because of course it would not work if anyone knew what he was up to. In this case, it seems that Shakespeare is highlighting a person's willingness to keep secrets for self gain, not to help anyone else. It's not possible to fully assess Shakespeare's intentions, however, without knowing how Edmund's plan works out.

"Kent: If but as (well) I other accents borrow
That can my speech diffuse, my good intent
May carry through itself to that full issue
For which I razed my likeness. Now, banished Kent,
If thou canst serve where thou dost stand
condemned,
So may it come thy master, whom thou lov'st,
Shall find thee full of labors." (1.4, 1-8).


This quote also shows the motif, because it is when Kent reveals his secret plan of disguising himself so he can go back and work for King Lear, who has banished him. I think that he is keeping his plan a secret because he is going to do something harmful to the king that can only be committed from the "inside". Also, there have been clues that maybe Cordelia knows about Kent's plan, and that would give the motif more insight regarding who keeps a secret, who they choose to tell, who they choose not to tell, and why. I'm not completely sure, but I think that like Edmund, Kent is keeping his secret for self-gain.

I need to find more examples of secrets to really assess their purposes, and also need to see how the secret plans created by Edmund and Kent turn out in order to come to a conclusion. So far, it seems like the secrets being used are secret plans of single characters created to somehow help the one character who created the plan. It also seems like the secret plans are harmful to others....that is why they have to be kept a secret in the first place - so no one finds out and prevents the plan from being executed.

Saturday, January 9, 2010

King Lear Journal 2

Respond to the character of the Fool - what characterizes his role/relationship to Lear? How do you perceive him?

I like the character of the Fool, because he brings humor to otherwise serious scenes. However, he is not only full of jokes - he also has good insights into the events happening in Lear's life and the decisions he makes. It almost seems like through the Fool's rhymes and songs, he is trying to give Lear advice, even though Lear doesn't pick up on much of it. An example of this is found in 1.4:
"Have more than thou showest,

Speak less than thou knowest,
Lend less than thou owest [...]" (122-124).
Lear's attempts at advice suggest that he is at least a middle-aged man, if not old. He speaks of life lessons that were likely gained from experience. His advice to the king also help the reader understand his relationship with Lear. The Fool is not afraid to tell Lear outright what he thinks, and he even goes so far as to plainly insult the king to his face, calling him a fool (several times). The Fool is a unique character because he actually gets away with it. I think Lear doesn't get seriously upset at the Fool for insulting him because he has had a long relationship with him, and realizes that Fool's actions are just part of who he is - an entertainer. If any of his daughters or kingsmen called him a fool, Lear would probably be much more upset, because he expects them to respect and honor him. However, the Fool is not expected of much, and the king takes what he says as jokes, not as anything serious. That is one of the reasons why Lear does not absorb the valuable advice the Fool tries to share with him. Likely, the advice that Lear ignores will end up hurting him when he does not follow it later on in the play.

Wednesday, January 6, 2010

King Lear Journal 1

In King Lear, Lear asks that his three daughters each profess their love to him before he gives them their inherited land and power. The first daughter to speak, Goneril, uses a language of flattery to profess her love for Lear. She includes flowery words and is in general overly dramatic and exaggerated. She compares her love for her father to many things, such as "grace, health, beauty, honor" (line 64) as well as "eyesight, space, liberty" (line 62), saying that she values her father's love over everything she has mentioned. Her overly exaggerated profession of love shows her selfishness as well as desperation. She only speaks with such flattery in hopes that she will receive the best piece of land her father is offering, and apparently does not think that a truly honest answer will earn it for her.
Regan is the second sister to speak, and like Goneril, she also uses language filled with flattery. She also takes the approach of trying to appear better than her sister. At one point, she says: "I find she names my very deed of love; / Only she comes too short" (lines 78-79). Her attempt to one-up Goneril shows not only her competitive nature, but her similar desire to win her father's good graces and recieve the best land. In a clearly overlydramatic last statement, Regan even goes so far as to declare herself "an enemy to all other joys" (line 80) besides her father's love. Again, this ingenuine statement highlights her desperation and selfish desires.
Cordelia is the last of the three sisters to speak. Unlike her sisters, she uses few words to profess her love for her father - however, what she says appears to actually be genuine. She does not take the approach of overexaggerated flattery, because she knows that whatever she says will not be able to compete with her sisters' over the top proclamations. Instead, she gives her father an honest answer by saying that she cannot give her father all of her love, because when she marries, her husband will receive half of her love too. "Haply, when I shall wed, / That lord whose hand must take my plight shall / carry / Half my love with him" (lines 110-113). This earnest statement shows that Cordelia is more honest than her sisters. They likely love their husbands as much as or more than their father, therefore their claims that they only love their father are simply empty compliments. Cordelia is honest and genuine, because she is willing to express her true feelings, unlike her sisters. In addition, Cordelia's declaration highlights her bravery - her opinion is sure to be rejected, and she will likely be punished for insulting her father the king, but she speaks her mind anyway.


Sunday, December 13, 2009

Blood Wedding Journal #3

Themes and Ideas

It seems to me that through Blood Wedding, Lorca is trying to express his belief that true love does not last. Even if it exists for a little while, eventually one of the people in the relationship will find someone else and move on to them. In the book, we see this idea clearly through Bride, Bridegroom, Leonardo, and Wife. Bride and Bridegroom are getting married, and Leonardo and Wife are already married; however, at her own wedding, Bride runs away with Leonardo because she still has feelings for him (as he still loves her). We see Leonardo's feelings for Bride when he says: "To keep still while we're on fire is the worst punishment we can inflict on ourselves. What good did it do me to have pride? - and not see you? - and leave you lying awake, night after night? No good at all!" (Lorca 47). In their action of running away, Bride and Leonardo break up two marriages, therefore causing Bridegroom and Wife to see that their ex lovers no longer love them. This theme is also confirmed through Lorca's own personal life that influenced the writing of this play. In 1928, Lorca became involved with Emilio Aladren, a young sculptor. A year later, Emilio left Lorca and became involved with a woman who he would eventually marry. This event caused Lorca to fall into a depression, and it makes sense that his personal life experiences would bleed into his writing, therefore portraying the same belief about temporary love that he went through himself.

Blood Wedding Journal #2

"What is drama but life with the dull bits cut out?" To what extent do you find this statement applicable in at least two plays you have studied?

This statement can only de determined true or false by looking at individual plays. In Ibsen's Wild Duck, the statement is not applicable. The play was written to involve more common aspects of life, rather than only high intenstiy scenes. Since Wild Duck is a work of drama, this statement does not hold true to it. Ibsen wrote this play during a period of time when plays were moving from romanticism to modernism, and in modernism, it was more common for the "tragic hero" to be low or middle class. Therefore, a lot of the moments in Ibsen's book just revolve around dull, ordinary parts of life. For example, in Act 2, Gina and Hedvig dicuss the dull, simple matter of finances and budgeting:
"Gina: Do you remember how much we spent for the butter today?
Hedvig: It was one sixty five.
Gina: That's right. It's awful how much butter gets used in this house" (Ibsen 138).
This scene is just one of many that showcase the ordinary aspects of life represented ni Wild Duck, proving that drama can also be life with the dull bits left in.

However, in Lorca's Blood Wedding, the statement proves to be applicable for the most part. There are not a lot of very dull scenes portraying common parts of life. Instead, the play shows life without the dull parts. There always seems to be some action going on, or if not extreme action, then at least something that would not be classified as boring or ordinary. One scene in Act 2 that represents the truth of the statement (what is drama but life with the dull bits cut out) is when the families realize that Leonardo and Bride have run off together:
"Mother: What is it? Where is your daughter?
Wife: They ran away! They ran away! She and Leonardo! On the horse! They rode off in each other's arms, like a bolt of lightning!" (Lorca 76).
This scene proves the statement true because it is definitely not dull or ordinary. It is not a common thing for a bride to run away from her wedding with her ex-boyfriend, especially without telling anyone. This moment of intensity does in fact show that Lorca's kind of drama revoloves around portraying life with the dull bits cut out.

Thursday, December 10, 2009

Blood Wedding Journal #1

"Visual action can be as important on the stage as speech." How far do you agree with this claim? Refer to two or three plays.

I agree with this claim. Visual action is not always as important as speech, but it can be as important sometimes. In Oedipus The King, visual action is not as important on the stage as speech. The dialogue is very detailed and expressive, and shows the reader exactly what the characters are feeling. In this case, visual action is not necessary to understand the exact meaning of the play - the audience easily picks up on it based off of dialogue alone. It is not extremely significant to know where the actors are on the stage, the props they use, or the gestures they make, because the dialogue alone tells the story. The only stage cues in the play are when someone enters or exits a scene. Here is an example of the expressive dialogue used by Sophocles in the play, when Oedipus is upset at Creon for "scheming against him".
"You - here? You have the gall
to show your face before the palace gates?
You, plotting to kill me, kill the king -
I see it all, the marauding thief himself
scheming to steal my crown and power!" (lines 594-598).
With this dialogue, Oedipus' anger is very obvious simply by the language he uses, and visual action is not essential to understand his feelings.

However, in Blood Wedding, visual action is as important as speech, if not more. This is because the dialogue Lorca writes in is very simple. He uses short, to-the-point words that create a huge sense of ambiguity in determining characters' true feelings and meanings of their conversations.
Here is an example of the dialogue in the play:
"Bridegroom: I'll come tomorrow.
Bride: At what time?
Bridegroom: At five.
Bride: I'll be waiting for you." (Lorca, 34-35).
In this case, it would be very helpful to have visual action to aid in understanding. It is extremely difficult to tell what the bride and her groom are thinking and feeling. It seems like there is no feeling involved in their brief exchange; however, if there was visual action to refer to, there might be a hint of something, such as a certain facial expression, a wink, a hug, etc. that would give the reader more of an idea about what is going on. When speech is so plain and emotionless, it is necessary to have visual action to pick up any sort of meaning.

Wednesday, December 9, 2009

Wild Duck Journal #5

"Although doubt is not a pleasant condition, certainty is an absurd one." In the light of this statement, explore the impressions of doubt and/or certainty conveyed in at least two works you have studied.

I understand this statement to mean that while people do not like to be in a position of doubt, a condition of certainty is an absurd idea because it is almost impossible to obtain exact certainty. In Oedipus the King, Oedipus gets upset with Tiresias when he will not tell him directly who the murderer of Laius is. He is uncomfortable not knowing the truth, and even when Tiresias tells him he does not want to hear it, Oedipus says: "What? You know and you won't tell?/ You're bent on betraying us, destroying Thebes?" (lines 376-377). After learning the truth, Oedipus is still not in a position of certainty, because he does not actually believe Tiresias when he says that Oedipus is the murderer of Laius and at fault for the plague. While he hated not knowing Tiresias' news, Oedipus is not content knowing the news either because he sees it to be untrue and is greatly offended by it. In this case, Sophocles shows us that it is better to be in the unpleasant condition of doubt than to try to obtain the impossible condition of certainty.

In Wild Duck, Hedvig finds herself in a position of doubt. She starts to pick up on tensions around the house and wants to know why her father does not want to see her anymore. Hedvig, like any typical person, does not like being in the dark about her situation, so she tries to replace her doubt with certainty. She asks Gregers about it, thinking that she can trust him to help her find the complete truth. However, like Oedipus, she soon realizes that certainty is indeed an unrealistic condition when Gregers avoids telling her the truth by saying: "That's something you mustn't ask until you're big and grown-up" (Ibsen, 196). Ibsen uses Hedvig to show that it is somewhat better to be stuck in a condition of unpleasant doubt than it is to be constantly disappointed by trying to reach certainty and realizing it is impossible.

Tuesday, December 8, 2009

Wild Duck Journal #4

Dear Diary,

How could Hedvig not be my own daughter?? I can't believe that Gina kept this big secret from me for fourteen years. I'm so upset with her! Gregers and I just discussed the ideal marriage, and he made me believe that me and Gina still had a chance to achieve it. I wonder if Gregers knew the whole time! What the worst part of this whole predicament is that Hedvig's real father, Old Werle, is going blind....so now I know for sure that poor Hedvig will too! I feel so sorry for her, especially since she doesn't know. But I can't even stand to look at her anymore, now that I know she does not belong to me. This whole house is corrupted. I have to get away frmo it all! Away from the poor girl, away from my deceitful wife, away from that stupid wild duck that came from the same old man who had an affair with my own wife. If it wasn't for Hedvig, I would have strangled that duck by now. So I must leave this house, this twisted, agonizing mess, before I do something completely crazy. I don't know where I'm going to go, or what I'm going to do there, but I know that I jsut can't stay here any longer. Perhaps I will go somewhere to finish my invention. Although, I'm only making it for the benefit of my family, and to pay off that awful old man of my debts. So I guess it's not even important anymore. Without my family and a need to complete my invention, I'm completely lost. I don't know what to do. Hopefully there is a solution to all this craziness...

- Hjalmar

Monday, December 7, 2009

Wild Duck Journal #3

A dramatist often creates a gap between what the audience knows and what the characters know. With reference to at least two plays, discuss how and to what effect dramatists have used this technique.

In Wild Duck, it seems that the characters know more information than the reader does, regarding their past and backgrounds especially. Ibsen has created a sense of ambiquity by purposefully leaving details out. For example, in Act 1, Ibsen shares little information about the scandal that Ekdal and Werle were involoved in. Hjalmar says when speaking to Gregers: "They were such very different circumstances I found myself in. But then everything else was so different, too. That immense, shattering misfortune for Father - the shame and scandal" (Ibsen 123). Here, Ibsen does not tell give away much about the scandal, leaving the reader to wonder what happened. By doing so, Ibsen forces the reader to make connections of their own to the context of the play and try to discover for themselves what the two men might be referring to. By using the characters to withhold information, Ibsen helps to build them up as characters as well. From this passage, we see Hjalmar's unwillingness to go into detail, which makes the reader wonder if he feels ashamed or embarrassed.
In Act 3 of Wild Duck, Ibsen once again uses Hjalmar to withhold information from the audience. This time the ambiguity appears when he is briefly telling Gregers about his invention, and Gregers asks: "And what does this invention consist of? What's its purpose?" (Ibsen 168). To this, Hjalmar answers: "Yes, Gregers, you musn't ask for details like that yet" (Ibsen 168). By not telling the reader (or Gregers) what his invention is, Hjalmar causes us to wonder what it is and why it is so important to his future. It seems that the other characters know what it is, like Hedvig and Gina, so that leaves the reader to wonder why the audience and Gregers cannot know. The one reason that I can think of for this is if it is an invention that Gregers will not like for some reason, or something that will hurt him or his father. but anyway, once again Ibsen has chosen to withhold certain information from the audience to inspire them to think of what it could possibly be.
Opposite to Wild Duck, in Oedipus The King, Sophocles gives the audience more knowledge about what's going on than the characters themselves. From the beginning of the play when Oedipus' prophecy is mentioned ("Revealed at last, brother and father both/ to the children he embraces, to his mother/ son and husband both - he sowed the loins/ his father sowed, he spilled his father's blood!" [Sopohocles 520-526] ), the reader can clearly see that Oedipus is the murderer of Laius, his father, and is the son of Jocasta, his wife. Since the reader goes on throughout the rest of the story knowing what the characters will soon discover, there is less suspense. Also, because the audience has been set up to know more than the characters, the technique of dramatic irony has been created. This dramatic irony makes the tragedy more enjoyable to the reader, because although they already know what is going to happen, they have to wait and see how the characters will react.

Friday, December 4, 2009

Wild Duck Journal #2

Stylistic Techniques: The use of symbolism

One of the techniques that I found in Act 2 of Wild Duck is symbolism. I think that Hedvig's wild duck acts as a symbol for who Gregers will become in the future. Before the duck was caught by Werle, it was content with its life in the wild. However, now that it has been away from nature for so long, the Ekdals assume that it is content where it is because it doesn't remember its old life anyway. Hjalmer says: "I think she's been in there so long, too, that she's forgotten her old wild life, and thats what it all comes down to" (Act 2). Like the duck, Gregers has left his old town and life to move back to the city. He is unsure of his future because he doesn't quite fit in the same way that he used to in the city, and he isn't exactly sure what his new job will be. It seems that he is not looking to permanently stay in the city. Through the symbol of the duck, Ibsen suggests that Gregers, given time, will completely adjust back to life in the city. Perhaps things will go right back to the way they were (regarding his family troubles), which is not the favorable outcome. But since the duck has been able to adjust to life out of the wild and forget his old life, I believe the same will happen to Gregers. After deciding to rent the Ekdal's spare room, Gina tries to dissaude him by telling him that it is small and nothing fancy. Gregers replies by saying: "One gets used to that soon enough. I'm hoping things will go for me the same as with the wild duck" (Act 2). It seems Gregers is already aware of and willing to accept his inevitable fate of returning to a monotonous old life.

Thursday, December 3, 2009

Wild Duck Journal #1

Point of view/characters: From whose point of view is the story told? Does this change? How reliable is the narrative voice? How well does the reader get to know the characters? How credible are they? How are they presented? How does the writer persuade us to like/sympathize with some characters and dislike others?

In Wild Duck, the main narrator so far is Gregers. I know he is the narrator because he shows up fairly quickly at the beginning of the play, and is the character Ibsen focuses the most on at this point, as he follows Gregers' conversations with various people. The narrator hasn't changed yet, but at this point in the play (Act 1), it is hard to know if it will. I feel like Gregers is reliable. From his conversations, I do not get the impression that he is trying to hide anything, and in contrast to his father, during their conversation he is the one interested the most in talking about the truth. Although it is early in the play, we have gotten to know the characters fairly well, especially Gregers, Werle, Hjalmar, and Ekdal. Since Gregers is the narrator and therefore seems to be the protagonist, Ibsen has set him up to be liked by the reader. He wants to know the truth from his father about the forestry scandal, wants to take time to catch up with his childhood friend Hjalmer, and pities the poor condition that Ekdal is in. All of these are admirable qualities and present Gregers as a fine man. On the other hand, Werle was not set up to be liked by the readers. Ibsen uses the conversation between Werle and his son, Gregers, to emphasize Werle's bad qualities: his lack of guilt for going unpunished while his friend Ekdal suffered ("But the fact remains that he was convicted and I was acquited," Act 1, 131), his lack of sympathy for the poor old man's condition ("Seriously, what would you have me do for these people? When Ekdal was let out, he was a broken man, beyond any help" (Act 1, 131), and his open admittance of simply using his son ("In a relatinoship as close as ours, one can always be of use to the other" Act 1, 134). By highlighting these negative qualities in Werle, Ibsen convinces the reader to relate more to his son. Ibsen also causes us to sympathize with Ekdal, the old man, simply by his physicality and short appearance in this act. When he walks through the party dressed in dirty clothing looking extremely out of place, causing all of the guests to look down on him, the reader cannot help but feel at least a little sorry for him.

Wednesday, December 2, 2009

Oedipus Journal #4

"Not rounding off, but opening out." Comment upon the way the writers deal with the ending in relation to the whole.

In the end of Oedipus the King, Jocasta has committed suicide after finding out that Oedipus is her son, Oedipus has stuck brooches in his eyes to make himself blind as a punishment for never truly seeing what was in front of him, and Creon is apparently assuming the role of King of Thebes. The way Sophocles wrote this ending does not "round off" the play because it does not really tie up all the loose ends and satisfy the reader. Instead, it "opens out", meaning that it simple opens the door for many possibilities regarding what could happen next. For example, after reading the end of the play, the reader is left not knowing what will happen to Oedipus' children (will Oedipus' prophecy move down to them?), what kind of leader Creon will be, if anything will be done about the state's plague, and even what will happen to Oedipus if he lives the rest of his life in exile. By creating an ending such as this one in which questions remain unanswered, Sophocles has left the fate of the characters fairly open-ended, leaving the reader to interpret the possibilities for themselves. In a way, this kind of ending is unsatisfactory, because as a reader I would rather leave a book once all the loose ends have been tied up, not before things have been completed.

In The Crucible, Miller also creates an unsatisfying ending. Although Proctor has agreed to confess to witchcraft - a crime he did not commit - in order to save his life, he soon changes his mind and in turn gets hanged for his decision. While Proctor does this to save his honor, it is not what the reader wants to happen. It would have been preferable if Proctor had stayed alive, then the reader could have followed his actions and seen him possibly end the accusations and chaos around him. Instead, the reader leaves the story uncertain as to when the witchcraft trials will stop (or if they will stop at all), if Abigail and the other accusers will be revealed as frauds, and the state of the town and its people in the aftermath of the event. By creating an ending that does not "round off" but "opens out", Miller forces the reader to interpret for themselves what lies in the future for the characters of the story.

Tuesday, December 1, 2009

Oedipus Journal #3

Setting: This includes cultural as well as geographical and historical setting. What effect does the setting have on story, character, theme?

This tragedy is set in Thebes, a state in ancient Greece. Based on the historical aspect of ancient Greece, I will be discussing importance of setting in the story. As we learned, gods and religion were a huge part of Greek life. Everyday citizens and kings alike both looked to the gods for answers to the questions they had about life, prophecies on things to come, and guidance in difficult situations. In Oedipus The King, this setting involving the importance of gods creates the whole conflict developed so far. For example, if our city today was faced with a plague like the one Thebes suffers under, we would likely tighten up health and safety procedures to see where it started and to stop it from spreading. However, in Thebes, the citizens look to the gods for answers - specifically to answer the question of what (or who) is responsible for bringing this plague upon the city. When Oedipus does get an answer from the gods, it is not something that he wants to accept. This creates a separate conflict in the story, in the form of the struggle between man and the gods. As for affecting characters, the setting of ancient Greece creates specific gender roles for men and women. As was common in Greek life, the men in the story speak of themselves with important and in general they are held in higher esteem than the women are. However, as was also common in early Greek plays, there were few women in plays, but the ones present played important roles. We learned that Greek women were sometimes known for their hidden wisdom, and we see this stereotype filled through the role of Jocasta. When she is introduced in the play, she quickly establishes herself as very knowledgeable - she is able to tell Oedipus all about Laius' murder and the prophecy regarding it. However, she seems to hold back some information, leading the reader to believe that she knows more than she lets on. This connects back to the secret knowledge held by female characters in Greek dramas.

Monday, November 30, 2009

Oedipus Journal #2

A letter from Creon to Oedipus:

Dear Oedipus,

I'm writing to you as an attempt to persuade you to think about the current situation in a more sensible way. You have strongly accused me of being involved in an intricate plot to overthrow you from your position as king. Since Tiresias hinted that you are the one responsible for Laius' murder, and I was the one who sent for Tiresias, you seem to believe that I have created a conspiracy against you by framing you as his murderer. In your assumptions, you have concluded that I have created this scheme so that I may gain more power of my own. However, I ask that you stop pointing your finger at me and listen to the truth. Why would I desire more power than what I currently possess? You and I rule the land of Thebes with equal power, so why would I need to overthrow you at all? We rule with the same amount of authority, and I do not desire the full kingship simply because of the many extra duties there are to perform. Besides, the people of Thebes adore you as their ruler, and I do not have the ability to step into such a role. Oedipus, I am your friend, and I cannot fathom why you have so suddenly turned against me. If your problem is with Tiresias' vision, then take up your argument with him. Perhaps you heard him incorrectly and jumped to unfair accusations as a means of defending your honor. This scheme of mine exists solely in your mind, and it is an insane accusation for one to make against his own friend. I ask you to reconsider what has happened; maybe after some time to think you will have come to your senses and snapped out of this moment of insanity. But for me, all I ask from you is that you let me reign peacefully alongside you, and spare me the banishment or execution reserved for a man who is truly guilty.

Sincerely, Your friend and kinsman,
Creon

Sunday, November 29, 2009

Oedipus Journal #1

"Defiance becomes our duty in the face of injustice." Referring to at least two works you have studied, explore the ways in which writers have attempted to persuade us to accept or challenge this view.

In Oedipus The King, when Oedipus is accused of being the murderer of Laius by the blind prophet Tiresias, his first instinct is to defend himself, by denying that it is true. He turns against the blind prophet who he had trusted to give him accurate information, insulting him and accusing him of having lost his prophecy powers. His defiance increases as he says to Tiresias: "Come here, you pious fraud. Tell me,/ when did you ever prove yourself a prophet?" (443-444). Oedipus' cruel attitude is a major change from the well mannered, easygoing attitude we saw him possess when he was first introduced to us at the beginning of the tragedy. Because Tiresias is accusing Oedipus of something that seems completely ridiculous and completely impossible to him, Oedipus feels the need to defend himself and his honor against the unjust accusations. The author, Sophocles, uses the contrast between the two attitudes to show that defiance becomes one's duty in the face of injustice, or rather, it is instinctive for one to act out defiantly when they face unfair accusations.


Likewise, in the book 1984, author George Orwell persuades the audience to accept this view of defiance in the face of injustice. When Winston is caught and imprisoned by the Thought Police for committing thought crime and acts against the party, he clings to his own beliefs as long as he can. Even though O'Brien spends months trying to persuade him to accept the idealogy of the Party, for the longest time Winston will not forget his own values. When forced to speak in favor of the Party or be hurt by a shock machine, Winston publicly defends his own ideals even though he is hurt because of it. Winston's acts of defiance against the Party continue until he is completely brainwashed into loving the Big Brother. Orwell uses Winston's reaction to his situation (the injustice of being imprisoned for trying to live as an individual) to show the reader that when one is faced with an unfair or unjust situation, it is an instinctive reaction to show defiance.

Tuesday, November 3, 2009

Poetry Journal: XX Comparison

The work I will be comparing to Neruda's poem XX is the chorus from the song "Tattoo", written by Amanda Ghost and Ian Dench (performed by Jordin Sparks).
Don’t look back got a new direction
I loved you once, needed protection
You’re still a part of everything I do
You’re on my heart just like a tattoo
Just like a tattoo
I’ll always have you
I'll always have you


Neruda's poem (XX) is about a man coming to terms with the end of a relationship. In the poem, the
speaker tries to convince himself that he has moved on from the woman he once loved, but we
can see that she is still important to him, and he actually still loves her. One of the ways Neruda
highlights this idea is through the repetition of the line: "I no longer love her, that's certain".
Because the speaker uses this line more than once in this poem, it seems as if he does not believe
what he is saying, so he must say it multiple times to try to make himself believe it. Although he
wants to move on and move forward with his life, the speaker cannot convince himself that he is
really over his previous girlfriend. Another technique used by the poet to convey this idea is the use
of the terms "her" and "she" when referring to the woman. Because the speaker dose not use the
woman's actual name when talking about her, we can see that he is doing his best to forget about her
by de-personalizing their relationship. However, his love for her gets the best of him as we see through
the numberous amounts of times he brings her up (using "her" and "she" - 30 times). Although the
speaker has attempted to move on from the relationship, he cannot because he still loves the woman.

Like the poem (XX), "Tattoo" is about the end of a relationship, and somebody being forced to move on. Unlike the
speaker in the poem, the speaker in the song seems very willing to move forward. We can see that she wants to

move on with her life through the line
"
Don’t look back got a new direction". The speaker in Neruda's poem is
much more hesitant - he knows he will have to move on, but is not completely willing to let go of the
relationship yet. Since the speaker in the song is much more accepting of the fact that she will have to move on,
she is also more willing to embrace the fact that since she used to love him, he will never be completely erased
from her life. This point is emphasized through the use of the simile "you're on my heart just like a tattoo". In
using this simile, the writer of the song emphasizes the permanent effects the relationship has had
(and will continue to have) on the speaker. This idea is proved even more through the repetition of the line
"I'll always have you". The reader leaves this song chorus knowing that the speaker is ready to move on from
a past relationship while acknowledging the fact that the person she used to love will be on her heart "just like
a tattoo" for the rest of her life. The person leaving this relationship is much stronger and self-assured than the
speaker leaving the relationship in Neruda's poem.

Monday, November 2, 2009

Poetry Journal: XIII

This poem is about a relationship between a man and a woman. Although the man and women have had a physical relationship, they do not have a strong emotional relationship because the man has trouble fully expressing his feelings toward the woman. In addition, there is some kind of distance separating them that weakens their relationship. The man speaks of the woman possessively, as if he owns her. However, it is seen in more of a protective way than a controlling way, as he wants her to be happy and tries to cheer her up when she is sad. At the end of the poem, the man faces the consequences of his inability to share his feelings and ends up closing himself off from love.

The speaker of the poem is a man speaking to a woman from his past who he loved but lost. To me, it seems like he is speaking to her out of regret. The distant tone of the poem suggests that while the man knows it is too late to get the woman back, he still wants to attempt to tell her his feelings that he could never express before.

This poem was written to show how important communication is in a relationship. The speaker finds out that because he is unable to let the woman know how he feels about her early on, he is forced to deal with the consequences this brings - likely heartbreak. The last stanza of the poem hints that the speaker is now alone and closed off from love. Although in this poem the speaker tries to share his feelings, it is too late for him to win his love back. The poet is trying to emphasize that one must share their thoughts and feelings with the other person in a relationship soon, because if they do not, they will create distance between them and one person will eventually move on.

The poet uses the repetition of the word "something" in the fourth stanza to emphasize the speaker's inability to express himself. By using of this general word instead of naming the specific object at hand, the speaker is able to get by without fully communicating his thoughts. We see the speaker's possession of the woman through the terms he uses when addressing her: "sad and gentle doll", "my toy doll", "my sad tenderness". By calling her a doll and using the possessive pronoun "my", the speaker objectifies the woman and seems to take ownership of her. The simple yet intense verbs used at the end of the poem when the speaker has lost the woman convey a different mood than previous stanzas. In previous passages when the woman is still in his life, the speaker uses terms like "loved" and "dream" when speaking, but now that she is gone he resorts to terms like "burn" and "flee". We can see that the consequences he now faces that involve the loss of his loved one have changed him and his mindset.

Tuesday, October 27, 2009

1984 Journal #3: Topic C

In 1984, Orwell creates a very powerful vision of a society in which the amount of governmental control in the everyday lives of its citizens is overly exaggerated. Orwell uses this powerful exaggeration as a wake up call to demonstrate what can happen if our government obtains too much power, and if we, as citizens, allow them to maintain so much power. While the society of Oceania that Orwell has created conveys a powerful message of warning to the reader, I do not find it to be very believable. Some of the things the government does to control its citizens would be impossible in today's world. For example, one of the main ways the government abuses their complete power is through their manipulation of history. They erase events, make up new ones, and alter others, recording all changes in the history books that only they can write. In today's world, however, there are way too many places we look for historical facts for the government to shut down or destroy every last one of them. I also don't think that the people of our society today would allow for so much government control without rebelling, simply because we have experienced freedom and will never settle for living oppressive lives. The only sort of hope I was able to find in the book is what Winston discovers - that if there is any hope of overthrowing the government, it must come from the proles. In other words, it is up to the common people of a society to come together when they recognize any sort of abuse of power happening in the government and to take action against it before it is too late.

Monday, October 26, 2009

Group Essay Thesis

Possible thesis:

Throughout 1984, Orwell uses repetition of the governmental slogan "war is peace, freedom is slavery, ignorance is strength". By doing so, he highlights the unquestioning belief in it by citizens of the society, ultimately expressing the the idea that humans find it easier to conform to an idea presented by others than to follow their own individual beliefs.

Please, please, please help make this better :). If it doesn't make sense, go ahead and fix it, or add any other thesis ideas you have. For this one, I was thinking that maybe places in the book where it is used are situations in which citizens of Oceania are showing some sort of agreement with it, like one time when it is used is during the Two Minutes Hate at the beginning of the book. This topic is kind of hard to analyze though. So I'll keep thinking.